NA, QM 2/11/1864

Quarter Master General's Department
Richmond, Feb 11th 1864
  
President Jefferson Davis
 
Mr. President,
   I have the honor to return herewith a letter of Hon. H. V. Johnson, covering a communication from His Excellency Govr Brown of Georgia, referred to me "for report." I beg leave also to enclose a copy of my letter of 21st January 1864, to General J. E. Johnston, and the report of Lt. Col. Sims, touching the subject matter of these letters. I have but little to add to what is contained in the two papers last named, as they give all the facts and figures which seem to be necessary.
   The action of this Department, in reference to the supply of rolling stock to Railways in need, has not been what Govr Brown appears to indicate. The arrangements to secure Stock, which has been withdrawn from territory overrun by the enemy, have generally been made between the two roads interested, the Agents of the Government intervening and mediating to ascertain where the Stock is most needed, and to assist in settling the terms etc. etc. A large proportion of the Stock thus leased or hired by the other Roads has been brought through Atlanta, and remained at or near that point for many weeks. If this deficiency on the Western & Atlantic Rail Road was foreseen by Govr Brown, he had abundant opportunity to secure the necessary Stock, then lying idle at one terminus of his road, and this Department would gladly have assisted in the negotiation. But it is evident that no such necessity existed, either in the opinion of Govr Brown or any official of the Government connected with Railway Transportation.
   The trains called for by Govr Brown can be furnished by taking them away from the line between Georgia & Virginia; but I fear the result would be disastrous to the supply of the Armies in the latter State. As to the claim that the Confederate Government should return what has been lost by the exigencies of war, it is simply asking what it is impossible to perform, even though it should appear that Colonel Sims is mistaken, and that heavy losses to this Road have been occasioned by the orders or interference of Confederate Officers.
A. R. Lawton, Q. M. Genl.

Home